Well, hello October! I’m so glad you’re here – I feel like I can officially start celebrating all things fall-ish. Seeing as how it’s still in the high 90’s, the -ish part of fall is a real factor.
I was super intimidated to try making whoopie pies – not a cookie and sort of cake – they seemed just prime to mess up. But not only did they come out beautifully, they were delicious. Not too sweet, a little spongy and just dense enough to not crumble everywhere.
I read about a dozen recipes before deciding to try Martha Stewart’s Whoopie Pie recipe. She uses a 1 ounce scoop for hers – and I used the ice cream scoop in my drawer, whatever size it might be. It’s important to use a consistent size amount of cookie dough, since you’ll want the two sides to match up.
The cookie/cakes bake beautifully and puff and not spread too much. I think I would like to try a recipe that yielded a “flatter” cookie.
Martha’s recipe calls for a 7 minute frosting – and the majority of recipes I read suggested a stiff frosting with meringue or cream cheese. In the spirit of experimenting, I tried this box frosting – and I was delighted with the result. I had intentions of using the cookie icing like a royal icing to adhere the monster eyes but the stiff frosting did a better job holding everything into place.
Divide the frosting into separate bowls and color your monster’s guts if you choose.
Spread a generous dollop of frosting on the flat (bottom) side of a cookie and top with the bottom of another to make a sandwich with two “tops” on the outside.
Add as many eyes as possible to make a cute stack of monster cookies (ahem, cookie monsters, if you will). I used some green embellishments around the edge of a few for extra mom points (V loves any kind of “sprinkle”!).